Court Exhibit·22 JUL 2020
Why Platforms Refuse the 'Just One Exception' Ask
The moment a platform grants one developer a private deal, it loses the argument for every other developer.
Source document — Epic v. Google — Email Thread: Consumer Choice & Competition (July 2020) · In re Google Play Store Antitrust Litigation (Epic v. Google) · 3:21-md-02981 (CAND), Doc. 887-41, filed 2023-12-21 (page 1)
Excerpt · In Tim Sweeney & Hiroshi Lockheimer's own words
If Google would allow Epic to launch direct Epic payments into Fortnite in August, and Google would agree to good faith discussions about a roadmap enabling third-party stores to operate through and at parity with Google Play in 2021, then our businesses would be 100% aligned in pursuit of Android as the leading mobile platform for games in the entirety of the Unreal Engine 5 generation. Our hope is that Google's learnings from a pilot launch in Fortnite would feed into a policy reevaluation benefitting all developers worldwide. I believe this direction would make Google an ally of all mobile game and app developers, at an undeniably critical point in the evolution of the tech industry. Epic would like to advance discussions on these two topics — agreement on payments and agreement to hold serious talks on store parity — to reach definite yes or no answers in July.
In reply, Hiroshi Lockheimer wrote: We are concerned that making exceptions for one developer would erode not only that ecosystem but our ability to provide those user benefits. Of course Don and I would be happy to talk with you about the concerns you've raised.
The daily letter · Free
This edition is for members — but the daily letter is free.
One real corporate email, and the lesson it teaches, in your inbox every weekday morning. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- In re Google Play Store Antitrust Litigation (Epic v. Google)
- Citation
- 3:21-md-02981 (CAND), Doc. 887-41, filed 2023-12-21
- Date authored
- July 22, 2020
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
More from Sundar Pichai
Don ·Google ·14 MAR 2023
Bundle Deals Across Divisions to Save a Weak Position
When one business unit can't justify the check alone, stack the strategic value across the whole company — or lose the partner entirely.
Tom Oliveri & Philipp Schindler & Hiroshi Lockheimer & John Giannandrea & Sundar Pichai ·Google ·26 AUG 2016
Never Run an Experiment You Can't Measure
If you can't measure it before you ship it, you're not experimenting — you're guessing with revenue.
Ruth Porat & Jamie Rosenberg ·Google ·21 JUL 2017
Conditional Payments: How Google Kept Samsung Honest on Defaults
The real deal isn't the revenue share — it's what you have to give up to earn it.
Shanna Velez & Mike Marchak & Purnima Kochikar & Alyssa Ablao & Josh Kim & Randy Gelber ·Google ·15 DEC 2021
Discounts Are Cheaper Than Exceptions to Your Pricing Rule
When you can't grant a carveout, invent a program — same economics, but the rule stays intact.
Don ·Google ·14 MAR 2023
Bundle Deals Across Divisions to Save a Weak Position
When one business unit can't justify the check alone, stack the strategic value across the whole company — or lose the partner entirely.
Karen Aviram Beatty & Lawrence Koh ·Google ·11 DEC 2019
Bundling Deals Can Backfire When Your Counterparty Wants Simplicity
When you stack asks to justify a payment, the other side sees complexity — and offers you a simpler exit.