Court Exhibit·19 JUL 2018
Choreograph the Meeting Before You Walk In
Great negotiators don't just prepare arguments — they stage-manage what the other side hears, when, and from whom.
Source document — In re Google Play Store Antitrust Litigation (Epic v. Google) — Exhibit 1517 · In re Google Play Store Antitrust Litigation (Epic v. Google) · 3:21-md-02981 (CAND), Doc. 887-5, filed 2023-12-21 (page 1)
Excerpt · In Purnima Kochikar & Jamie Rosenberg's own words
Thanks, Purnima. I copied into a doc and made some suggested edits. The line we're trying to walk is to try to get Mark on side in encouraging Tim to be open-minded, and giving just enough detail for Tim not to feel that it's an ambush of any sort (which it's not)... but also save some of our strongest points/specifics for the Friday discussion. I think as worded the script should be able to do that.
The tricky part will be if Mark asks directly, "So, are you guys prepared to make any changes on commercial terms for Play?" I think if he asks, you can just say, "For a lot of reasons, Hiroshi & Jamie want to have a different conversation -- they will explain on Friday."
— Jamie
---
Here's the draft script. We believe we are philosophically closer than what the previous call may have implied, and would like to have the opportunity to explore areas of collaboration with Tim. Then, Tim will meet Hiroshi (SVP of P&E), Jamie, and Phil Harrison. They are looking forward to presenting a comprehensive set of opportunities to partner with Google that will support Tim's objectives of supporting the dev ecosystem, making UE the best engine for innovation in gaming, and bring the joy of Fortnite to more gamers and viewers.
We also have a responsibility towards our users. Frankly, the experience of getting Fortnite on Android from the links Tim sent was frankly abysmal. This user experience and the security risks that come with it is giving us some real concern. There is a simpler way to get to what Tim wants without fracturing the user experience and the ecosystem.
The daily letter · Free
This edition is for members — but the daily letter is free.
One real corporate email, and the lesson it teaches, in your inbox every weekday morning. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- In re Google Play Store Antitrust Litigation (Epic v. Google)
- Citation
- 3:21-md-02981 (CAND), Doc. 887-5, filed 2023-12-21
- Date authored
- July 19, 2018
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
Shanna Velez & Mike Marchak & Purnima Kochikar & Alyssa Ablao & Josh Kim & Randy Gelber ·Google ·15 DEC 2021
Discounts Are Cheaper Than Exceptions to Your Pricing Rule
When you can't grant a carveout, invent a program — same economics, but the rule stays intact.
Don ·Google ·14 MAR 2023
Bundle Deals Across Divisions to Save a Weak Position
When one business unit can't justify the check alone, stack the strategic value across the whole company — or lose the partner entirely.
Karen Aviram Beatty & Lawrence Koh ·Google ·11 DEC 2019
Bundling Deals Can Backfire When Your Counterparty Wants Simplicity
When you stack asks to justify a payment, the other side sees complexity — and offers you a simpler exit.