Court Exhibit·11 FEB 2012
When Your Original Thesis Is Wrong, Pay To Fix It Fast
If a small competitor has already won the use case your future depends on, the cheapest option is usually to buy them — before the market figures out how valuable they are.
Source document — FTC v. Meta Platforms, Inc. — Exhibit PX1102 · FTC v. Meta Platforms, Inc. · 1:20-cv-03590 (DCD), Doc. 379-7, filed 2024-09-20
Excerpt · In Mark Zuckerberg's own words
I wonder if we should consider buying Instagram, even if it costs ~$500m.
Right now they seem to have two things that we don't: a really good camera and a photo-centric sharing network.
For the camera piece, their camera just takes photos that look much nicer than the native camera because of their filters, tilt-shift effects and even their new lux feature. I worry that it will take us too long to catch up, if we even will. And regardless, their brand is established as the awesome mainstream camera, so even if we catch up on features they're still the awesome iPhone camera app.
For the network piece, one concerning trend is that a huge number of people are using Instagram every day — including everyone ranging from non-technical high school friends to even FB employees — and they're only uploading some of their photos to FB. This creates a huge hole for us.
I think it's quite possible that our initial thesis was wrong and that theirs is right — that what people want is more to take the best photos than to put them on FB. If so, we'd be very behind in both functionality and brand on how one of the core use cases of Facebook will evolve in the mobile world, which is really scary and why we might want to consider paying a lot of money for this.
The daily letter · Free
This edition is for members — but the daily letter is free.
One real corporate email, and the lesson it teaches, in your inbox every weekday morning. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- FTC v. Meta Platforms, Inc.
- Citation
- 1:20-cv-03590 (DCD), Doc. 379-7, filed 2024-09-20
- Date authored
- February 11, 2012
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
More from Mark Zuckerberg
Nick Clegg & Kang-Xing Jin ·Meta Platforms, Inc. ·27 AUG 2021
Regulatory Pressure Is a Budget Argument
When your policy team is writing your product roadmap, you've already lost the timing war.
Margaret Stewart & Mark Zuckerberg & Sue Young & Nick Clegg & Monika Bickert & Naomi Gleit & Andy O'Connell ·Meta/Facebook ·12 MAY 2020
The Burden-of-Proof Trap in Product Decisions
When you require proof of harm before acting, you've already decided in favor of the risk.
Mark Zuckerberg & [REDACTED] ·Meta (Facebook) ·9 APR 2012
Buy The Threat Before It Becomes The Competitor
When a small player is beating you on a new behavior, acquisition can be cheaper than the fight.
Mark Zuckerberg & [REDACTED] ·Meta (Facebook) ·9 APR 2012
Buy The Threat Before It Becomes The Competitor
When a small player is beating you on a new behavior, acquisition can be cheaper than the fight.
David Ebersman & Dan Levy ·Meta (Facebook) ·16 APR 2012
After You Buy It, Don't Break It
The cost savings will still be there in a year. The momentum won't.
Raymond Endres & Alex Schultz & Javier Olivan ·Meta/Facebook ·22 FEB 2014
When Winning Removes Your Team's Reason to Fight
If you build a team's identity around beating a rival, buying that rival creates a morale crisis, not a celebration.