Court Exhibit·21 JUL 2017
Musk and Brockman Debate OpenAI's Future While Musk Gifts Founders Model 3s
A single email thread from mid-2017 captures OpenAI at the exact moment its founders were already sketching a path from nonprofit to for-profit to government project — while Musk was simultaneously cementing personal loyalty with early Tesla hardware.
Source document — Musk v. Altman (OpenAI) — Exhibit 16 · Musk v. Altman (OpenAI) · 4:24-cv-04722 (CAND), Doc. 351-19, filed 2025-11-07 (page 1)
Excerpt · In Elon Musk & Greg Brockman & Ilya Sutskever & Jared Birchall's own words
Greg Brockman: "100% agreed. We think the path must be: 1. AI research non-profit (through end of 2017) 2. AI research + hardware for-profit (starting 2018) 3. Government project (when: ??) Government project is helpful for financial resources, but crucial for security — don't know how to defend against Putin or North Korea otherwise. When ready, we must proactively form the project around us, rather than being slurped in against our will."
Elon Musk (responding to a NYT article on China's 2030 AI ambitions): "They will do whatever it takes to obtain what we develop. Maybe another reason to change course."
Elon Musk (separately, to the founding team): "By the way, in appreciation for what you've done to get OpenAI to where it is today, I would like to give you each a Founder Series Model 3. These are the earliest cars produced and are not available to the public. If there are a few others at OpenAI who you think also really deserve one (maybe Wojciech?), I am happy to do the same for them."
Ilya Sutskever: "Wow, thank you! This is a very kind gesture that we greatly appreciate. Yes, Wojciech definitely deserves it as much as we do, as does John Schulman."
Elon Musk: "Consider it done! Jared, please facilitate. Let's try to slot these four cars into next month's production."
Jared Birchall: "Will do. Guys — I'll reach out separately with details."
Members · Archive
This edition is for members.
The daily letter is free. The archive — every prior edition, fully searchable — is for members. Sign in to start your free week.
$3/month · $30/year · cancel anytime
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- Musk v. Altman (OpenAI)
- Citation
- 4:24-cv-04722 (CAND), Doc. 351-19, filed 2025-11-07
- Date authored
- July 21, 2017
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
More from Elon Musk
Sam Altman & Elon Musk ·OpenAI ·18 FEB 2023
How to Handle a Powerful Critic You Still Need
When a former ally attacks you in public, don't defend — pivot to asking what they'd do instead.
Mark Zuckerberg & Elon Musk ·Meta, Tesla/X ·13 DEC 2024
Zuckerberg Tells Musk Meta Backed His OpenAI Lawsuit
A brief December 2024 exchange reveals that Meta quietly aligned itself with Musk's legal challenge to OpenAI's nonprofit conversion, and that Zuckerberg moved immediately to manage the relationship directly.
Elon Musk & Andrej Karpathy ·OpenAI ·1 FEB 2018
If You Can't Win Open, Find a Cash Cow
Open research without a profit engine isn't idealism — it's free R&D for whoever has the bigger bank account.
Neal Mohan & David Rosenblatt & Marc Schraer & Sean Downey & Andrew Rutledge & Ruth Kirschner ·Google ·13 FEB 2009
Don't Compete on Price When You Own the Platform
When a rival slashes prices out of desperation, the answer isn't matching them — it's reminding your customers what game you're actually playing.
Neal Mohan & Eric Rosenblum ·Google ·20 AUG 2010
Keep New Businesses Focused, Not Merged
When a young business is fighting to establish itself, the worst thing you can do is bury it inside a bigger org chart.
Julie Sterling Osterling & Jonathan Bellack & Heidi O'brien & Chris Jansen & Brian Tomasette & Jason Sigalos ·Google ·29 SEP 2015
When Sales Can't Answer The Question, You Have A Strategy Problem
If your own sales team can't explain why you don't do the thing customers want, the market has already made the decision for you.