Court Exhibit·2 OCT 2018
Why Scale Is The Real Moat In Ad Auctions
In ad markets, scale isn't just an advantage — it's the price of admission to compete at all.
Source document — Microsoft 'Baja' Financial Model Presentation to Apple — October 2018 · United States v. Google LLC (Search) · 1:20-cv-03010 (DCD), Trial Ex. UPX0116 — DOJ public archive
Excerpt · In Kate Plikus's own words
Scale evidence: Impact from original Yahoo supply
Key Takeaways: We have empirical proof from our Yahoo! Search deal that incremental volume drives up RPMs. With the influx of Yahoo! Traffic into our ecosystem in 2012 we were able to realize a one-time boost to our RPMs driven by injection of scale. In addition, having a bigger marketplace enabled us to increase our innovation which had driven up our RPMs even further over the next couple years.
We believe that injection of Apple volume would enable us to realize RPM lifts from scale and innovation similar to the Yahoo! deal. We would expect that these lifts would help us get to [redacted] of Google on iPad and Mac in the US. In international markets we would be able to get to [redacted] of Google on iPhone.
Notes: RPM increases with scale as advertisers increase bids to be on top in the auction, and algorithms improve with more data. The curve is initially steep as small increases in scale meaningfully improve advertiser participation, making it possible to offset fixed cost of investing in another platform. Product innovation shifts performance to a higher RPM curve, not along the same curve. Most of subsequent performance improvements come from innovation and demand expansion.
Members · Archive
This edition is for members.
The daily letter is free. The archive — every prior edition, fully searchable — is for members. Sign in to start your free week.
$3/month · $30/year · cancel anytime
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- United States v. Google LLC (Search)
- Citation
- 1:20-cv-03010 (DCD), Trial Ex. UPX0116 — DOJ public archive
- Date authored
- October 2, 2018
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
Dario Amodei & Emil Michael ·Anthropic ·26 FEB 2026
How to Walk Away Without Burning the Bridge
When the other side rewrites your redlines into meaningless words, name the trick precisely — then keep the door open.
Sam Altman & Elon Musk ·OpenAI ·18 FEB 2023
How to Handle a Powerful Critic You Still Need
When a former ally attacks you in public, don't defend — pivot to asking what they'd do instead.
Mark Zuckerberg & Elon Musk ·Meta, Tesla/X ·13 DEC 2024
Zuckerberg Tells Musk Meta Backed His OpenAI Lawsuit
A brief December 2024 exchange reveals that Meta quietly aligned itself with Musk's legal challenge to OpenAI's nonprofit conversion, and that Zuckerberg moved immediately to manage the relationship directly.