Court Exhibit·25 JUN 2009
Control Who Builds On Your Platform Before You Open The Doors
Once you open a platform to everyone, you lose the right to choose who gets to compete with you on it — so pick your moment carefully.
Source document — Email from Neal Mohan to Jonathan Bellack et al. Re: PubMatic Ad Price Prediction (June 25, 2009) · United States v. Google LLC (Ad Tech) · 1:23-cv-00108 (VAED), Trial Ex. PTX0046 — DOJ public archive (page 1)
Excerpt · In Neal Mohan & Jonathan Bellack & Brad Bender & Ari Paparo's own words
We should discuss this offline. I'm not comfortable opening up the XFP APIs to the YMs at this point.
— Neal Mohan
Jonathan Bellack had written: We are not including the Yield Managers in the trusted tester program, but once we take the API public in Q3/Q4 when the GAM pubs upgrade, we won't be able to pick and choose who gets access. We will have a terms of service and can look at what non-compete constraints we might want, but I think we should be as inclusive as possible to drive platform stickiness. Plus there are not any APIs into the ad selection process due to latency concerns, so the yield managers won't be able to do dynamic allocation. They try a workaround like updating the CPM of network line items dynamically but our initial API quotas will likely put a limit on how up-to-date they could keep things. I also expect that over time we'll institute API charges for 3rd-parties like what AdWords does, so this is actually a good revenue opportunity too.
Neal Mohan had earlier noted: Of all the 3rd party developer categories, yield managers are the ones I am most nervous about in terms of access to our new XFP API. It's fine if they participate via the AdX seller APIs.
Members · Archive
This edition is for members.
The daily letter is free. The archive — every prior edition, fully searchable — is for members. Sign in to start your free week.
$3/month · $30/year · cancel anytime
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- United States v. Google LLC (Ad Tech)
- Citation
- 1:23-cv-00108 (VAED), Trial Ex. PTX0046 — DOJ public archive
- Date authored
- June 25, 2009
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
Mark Zuckerberg & Elon Musk ·Meta, Tesla/X ·13 DEC 2024
Zuckerberg Tells Musk Meta Backed His OpenAI Lawsuit
A brief December 2024 exchange reveals that Meta quietly aligned itself with Musk's legal challenge to OpenAI's nonprofit conversion, and that Zuckerberg moved immediately to manage the relationship directly.
Eddy Cue ·Apple ·10 JAN 2013
Turn a Competitor's Weakness Into Your Positioning Strategy
When a rival's business model forces them to behave in ways users dislike, that tension is your product opportunity.
Matt Fischer ·Apple Inc. ·21 AUG 2018
When Your Pricing Faces Pushback, Negotiate Before You Lose the Deal
The moment your partners consistently refuse your terms, you have two choices: lose them or adapt — and waiting too long to decide is its own decision.