Court Exhibit·26 JUL 2012
When You Lock Your Own Team Out of the Market
If your internal product can only win by being kept on a leash, you haven't built a strong product — you've just built a wall.
Source document — Email from Woojin Kim to Brad Bender re: Adding Tiers 7 & 8 Inventory to AdX (July 26, 2012) · United States v. Google LLC (Ad Tech) · 1:23-cv-00108 (VAED), Trial Ex. PTX0103 — DOJ public archive (page 1)
Excerpt · In Woojin Kim & Drew Bradstock & Allan Livingston's own words
Brad - Did you know that they're putting long-tail AFC onto AdX now? Weren't you involved in some discussions (strategic in nature) where the group decided to put long-tail AFC off of AdX for a good reason?
From an earlier message in the chain: "if GDN has access to the same AdX inventory as any other DSP out there, that weakens the value proposition of GDN as a buyside platform. If this is the case I would like to have GDN buy on all exchanges, not just AdX, since all our competitors are doing so. We want truly equal inventory access."
The response captured in the email: "GDN actually has exclusive access to long-tail AFC pubs in addition to the other stuff that is available thru AdX so don't worry. GDN is still differentiated on inventory access. No, you cannot buy on other exchanges; that will weaken the value proposition of AdX as a sellside platform."
Kim then reflects: "So at this point I (GDN as a buyer) am beginning to wonder why we only restrict GDN to AdX."
Context from Drew Bradstock: "The original thinking was that it was low-CPM, low-CTR long tail inventory but it turned out to behave closely to the other tiers. Matthew Young-Lai eventually felt it was fine to add and he is a tough judge of getting any weak inventory into AdX."
The daily letter · Free
This edition is for members — but the daily letter is free.
One real corporate email, and the lesson it teaches, in your inbox every weekday morning. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.
How this surfaced
- Source type
- Court Exhibit
- Case / record
- United States v. Google LLC (Ad Tech)
- Citation
- 1:23-cv-00108 (VAED), Trial Ex. PTX0103 — DOJ public archive
- Date authored
- July 26, 2012
- License
- Public domain
- Original
- View the primary source →
Don ·Google ·14 MAR 2023
Bundle Deals Across Divisions to Save a Weak Position
When one business unit can't justify the check alone, stack the strategic value across the whole company — or lose the partner entirely.
Karen Aviram Beatty & Lawrence Koh ·Google ·11 DEC 2019
Bundling Deals Can Backfire When Your Counterparty Wants Simplicity
When you stack asks to justify a payment, the other side sees complexity — and offers you a simpler exit.
Johan Heurlin & Lawrence Koh & Jamie Rosenberg ·Google ·27 MAR 2019
When a Big Partner Asks for a Discount, Reframe the Deal
The smartest concessions look like co-investment, not subsidies — same money, very different risk.